From our experience, the problem with non-genuine parts is the unpredictability of the quality.
I am not saying always buy genuine, only that it is worth checking the genuine price, quality & availability rather than just buying non-gen automatically.
There are a lot of good quality non-gen parts out there and there are also people supplying parts from the same people who supply the manufacturer. Furthermore, there are also people selling off surplus/obsolete genuine parts.
Unfortunately though, for every proper supplier there are plenty of cowboys & crooks as well.
Does anyone remember front wishbones breaking on Cavaliers/Astras? It turned out to be non-genuine parts being passed off as genuine. ie fakes. They were cheaper though!
Most people here prefer using Bosch quality wiper blades to something picked up off a market stall. That one is easy to tell and it is not a major problem if the part differs slightly in size/fit to the original one.
The question is though, how do you tell with (say) a set of pads and discs? Will they last as long? Will they stop the car as well in an emergency? Will they fade after excessive use?
I know I am biased but I value my life and the life of my family and I cannot afford to replace the engine on my car when the cambelt snaps early!
--