Advice req pls

John (7)

Usenet Archive
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Hi, I'm thinking of changing my car and would like to know if anyone can recommend a make and model in the UK that has power steering, air-conditioning in and plenty of head room.

Thanks

John
 
John said:
Hi, I'm thinking of changing my car and would like to know if anyone can recommend a make and model in the UK that has power steering, air-conditioning in and plenty of head room.

Citroen Berlingo Multispace can be got with all of those, plus they're very economical if fitted with the HDi lump.
 
John wrote:

Hi, I'm thinking of changing my car and would like to know if anyone can recommend a make and model in the UK that has power steering, air-conditioning in and plenty of head room.

How big a car? You can get practically *any* car with air con and PAS now. The only things you might not be able to get it on are things like Peroduas and Axioms.
 
Have a look at the Astra estate - loads of headroom. Also the Micras, believe it or not - deoends on how small you want to go.

For headroom generally, if the vehicle looks tall then thats a good place to start.

"John" wrote:

Hi, I'm thinking of changing my car and would like to know if anyone can recommend a make and model in the UK that has power steering, air-conditioning in and plenty of head room.

Thanks

John
 
Maybe a 1.4ltr that isn't a tin-can and not too pricey? (Vauxhall?)

John
 
John said:
Maybe a 1.4ltr that isn't a tin-can and not too pricey? (Vauxhall?)

Hmm. 1.4 as in 1.4 Fiesta / Punto / Corsa sized thing, or 1.4 Focus / Astra sized thing? TBH, a 1.4 Focus sized car will be fairly slow. As I said, you can get air con on anything :P. You could get a Skoda Fabia with air con and pas (I wouldn't be surprised if both were standard).
 
Doki said:
Hmm. 1.4 as in 1.4 Fiesta / Punto / Corsa sized thing, or 1.4 Focus / Astra sized thing? TBH, a 1.4 Focus sized car will be fairly slow. As I said, you can get air con on anything :P. You could get a Skoda Fabia with air con and pas (I wouldn't be surprised if both were standard).

1.6 Astra will use no more fuel than a 1.4, and possibly less fuel on motorways. In any case, I've found the1.6 astra to be far more economical than any 1.4 I've ever driven. 1.6 Focus should be a safe bet too.

Astra's seem solidly built, bar a few engine management niggles. They're dirt cheap to buy privately or at auction as the fleet industry floods the market with 1-3 year old examples. Dealers inflate the prices dreadfully though.

The best bet is to buy one privately, less than 3 years old and less than 60,000 miles. Its a very safe bet as vauxhall are extremely good at honouring their factory warranty, which is one of the most comprehensive I've ever seen. Do check the service history is complete, because in the event of an expensive warranty claim they may want to see whether it's been serviced properly.

Avoid smaller cars as they tend to be of lower build quality (notable exceptions being japanese), and worse value for money as they depreciate less. And don't believe that small cars are always more economical either. For example, the Dervman achieves an average of about 39mpg from the Ford Ka. I averaged 42mpg with the Astra.
 
DervBoy said:
Avoid smaller cars as they tend to be of lower build quality (notable exceptions being japanese), and worse value for money as they depreciate less. And don't believe that small cars are always more economical either. For example, the Dervman achieves an average of about 39mpg from the Ford Ka. I averaged 42mpg with the Astra.

That's got a lot to do with the Ka's stone age engine though.
 
Doki said:
That's got a lot to do with the Ka's stone age engine though.

No, not really; it's got a lot more to do with the fact that we live in York and spend a lot of time in the city boundaries. :(

Outside of the city, on longer trips, we typically record 43 - 47 mpg, ranging from 41 to 49 mpg. :)

So, not really a like-for-like comparison.
 
DervMan said:
No, not really; it's got a lot more to do with the fact that we live in York and spend a lot of time in the city boundaries. :(

Outside of the city, on longer trips, we typically record 43 - 47 mpg, ranging from 41 to 49 mpg. :)

So, not really a like-for-like comparison.

I forgot about that factor, sorry. So not a good comparision. On longer trips, I recorded a max/min of 45-49mpg though, so that's perhaps a better comparision

The Dervboy
 
"DervBoy" wrote:

"DervMan" wrote:

>
> No, not really; it's got a lot more to do with the fact that we live in York
> and spend a lot of time in the city boundaries. :(
>
> Outside of the city, on longer trips, we typically record 43 - 47 mpg,
> ranging from 41 to 49 mpg. :)
>
> So, not really a like-for-like comparison.

...

No worries!

On longer trips, I recorded a max/min of 45-49mpg though, so that's
perhaps
a better comparision

Aie. The Ka's biggest problem isn't the engine, but the relative aerodynamic inefficiency.
 
1.4's are cheaper on tax :-)

DervBoy said:
1.6 Astra will use no more fuel than a 1.4, and possibly less fuel on motorways. In any case, I've found the1.6 astra to be far more economical than any 1.4 I've ever driven. 1.6 Focus should be a safe bet too.

Astra's seem solidly built, bar a few engine management niggles. They're dirt cheap to buy privately or at auction as the fleet industry floods the market with 1-3 year old examples. Dealers inflate the prices dreadfully though.

The best bet is to buy one privately, less than 3 years old and less than 60,000 miles. Its a very safe bet as vauxhall are extremely good at honouring their factory warranty, which is one of the most comprehensive I've ever seen. Do check the service history is complete, because in the event of an expensive warranty claim they may want to see whether it's been serviced properly.

Avoid smaller cars as they tend to be of lower build quality (notable exceptions being japanese), and worse value for money as they depreciate less. And don't believe that small cars are always more economical either. For example, the Dervman achieves an average of about 39mpg from the Ford Ka. I averaged 42mpg with the Astra.
 
not by much...

"John" wrote:

1.4's are cheaper on tax :-)

"DervBoy" wrote:

>
> "Doki" wrote:
>
> >
> > John wrote:
> >
> > > Maybe a 1.4ltr that isn't a tin-can and not too pricey? (Vauxhall?)
...
said,
> you
> > can get air con on anything :P. You could get a Skoda Fabia with air
con
> and
> > pas (I wouldn't be surprised if both were standard).
>
> 1.6 Astra will use no more fuel than a 1.4, and possibly less fuel on
> motorways. In any case, I've found the1.6 astra to be far more
economical
> than any 1.4 I've ever driven. 1.6 Focus should be a safe bet too.
>
> Astra's seem solidly built, bar a few engine management niggles. They're
> dirt cheap to buy privately or at auction as the fleet industry floods
the
> market with 1-3 year old examples. Dealers inflate the prices dreadfully
> though.
>
> The best bet is to buy one privately, less than 3 years old and less
than
> 60,000 miles. Its a very safe bet as vauxhall are extremely good at
> honouring their factory warranty, which is one of the most comprehensive
> I've ever seen. Do check the service history is complete, because in the
> event of an expensive warranty claim they may want to see whether it's been
> serviced properly.
>
> Avoid smaller cars as they tend to be of lower build quality (notable
> exceptions being japanese), and worse value for money as they depreciate
> less. And don't believe that small cars are always more economical
either.
> For example, the Dervman achieves an average of about 39mpg from the
Ford
> Ka. I averaged 42mpg with the Astra.
>
>
> --
> The Dervboy
>
> Reply-to address is valid as required by my news server, but is a spam
box
> and is never read.
> My real e-mail address is thedervboy{at}btopenglobe{dot}com
> (substituting "globe" with "world").
>
>

---
 
Hi, I'm thinking of changing my car and would like to know if anyone can recommend a make and model in the UK that has power steering, air-conditioning in and plenty of head room.

Thanks

John

I'm not an expert, by any means, but I really would consider an older, larger car. What you'd save in mpg with a newer, smaller car, you'll make up in purchase price. It's worth noting here that a _huge_ amount of the average energy used by a car goes into it's manufacture, so getting a new fuel efficient car every year is far from energy efficient in the long run.

I've been driving a Citroen XM 2.0i Turbo for ages, it's just been the runabout. It's worth nothing now, but it's done 200k or so, and no signs of dying (despite a bit of abuse from me ;)). Basically 0 repairs (one electrical thing, fixed 3 years ago), etc either. The only thing about it is the turbocharger's gone very loud now (whines a lot), but only when accelerating. Heh, to be honest, I've grown to love the whine. Mine's not got air-con, but lots do have. The XM diesels are apparently more desirable, but there isn't anything wrong with the petrols. Have a look at Lexus's too, I've not had direct experience of these, but they're cheap as chips when you compare them to newer cars with the same features.
 
And don't believe that small cars are always more economical either. For example, the Dervman achieves an average of about 39mpg from the Ford Ka. I averaged 42mpg with the Astra.

Figures from Autocar:-

Test MPG Touring route MPG

Astra 1.4 Envoy 33 39

Ford Ka 33 50

The fuel consumption on any car depends a lot on driving style, so you need to compare like for like.
 
the tax difference only apply to the newer cars the older ones still go under the old style of pricing.
 

Latest threads

Back
Top